Why do you have to use a getter?

Question

I understand why you would use a setter - to validate input before setting it, for example. However, why do you have to use a getter? cant you just set the property, then use dot notation to access the value?
```JAVASCRIPT
let obj = {
    set name(input) {

let name = input.split(' ');
    this.firstName = name[0];
    this.lastName = name[1];

},

firstName: 'Kristian',
lastName: 'Woods'
}
obj.name = 'John Smith';
console.log(obj.name);
``` 
why do you need the getter? I'm confused
Thanks

Steven Parker · Answer

In the video example, the "name" property is actually built from two separate stored fields, so it is necessary to compute and return the composite value.
Your code shown here will return "undefined" from the attempt to access obj.name, since there's no field by that name, and the getter has not yet been defined.

Luis Marsano · Answer

I think this is one of those questions where the best answer is 'see for yourself'.
javascript
let test = { set name(input) { this.name = input } }
test.name = 'name'

Try it out and report back to us: you'll get an error.
Why that particular error?
Because you're using the setter inside itself, leading to unbounded recursion.
Even if you could make the setter assign a value without calling itself, e.g.,
javascript
test = { set name(input) {
    Object.defineProperty(this, 'name', {configurable: true, enumerable: true, value: input})
    console.log('still here')
} }
test.name = 'name'
test.name = 'name'

that overwrites the property and whatever accessor methods it had; notice the 2nd test.name = 'name' no longer logs 'still here'.
A technical explanation is the language's specification of property (http://www.ecma-international.org/ecma-262/#sec-property-descriptor-specification-type): a property is exclusively either a data property (stores values) or an accessor property (getter and setter methods).
Never both.
This is typical of all languages offering similar object-oriented features.

Welcome to the Treehouse Community

Looking to learn something new?

Kristian Woods

Kristian Woods

Why do you have to use a getter?

2 Answers

Steven Parker

Steven Parker

Luis Marsano

Luis Marsano